Menu of Hartford Steak Co. Tavern in Vermillion, South Dakota, USA

Menu Overview

Hartford Steak Co. Tavern, nestled at 7 Court St in Vermillion, SD, stands out as a classic, unpretentious steakhouse that champions quality and straightforward comfort food. Specializing in prime cuts like their celebrated Prime Rib and Filet Mignon, this tavern offers a hearty menu that appeals to steak lovers craving a genuine, satisfying meal.

Their Prime Rib is undoubtedly the crown jewel here. Offered in generous sizes, including a standout 22oz Prime Rib Special, this dish boasts tenderness and rich roasting that many patrons have praised for its flavor and perfect cooking. It’s served with a traditional baked potato, which you can customize with toppings, and a crisp lettuce wedge salad dressed in ranch or French dressing—an ideal balance to the meat’s richness. This pairing delivers a classic steakhouse experience that feels both filling and well-rounded.

For those who prefer a more refined cut, the Filet Mignon options impress. Notably, the 27oz Filet Dinner and the 9oz variation served with creamy mashed potatoes offer tender, melt-in-your-mouth texture. The addition of sautéed mushrooms or a Philly topper as sides enhances the depth of flavors without overshadowing the steak itself. Harvey’s burger selection, such as the Blue Cheese Burger and BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger, adds diversity and caters to casual diners seeking a robust bite with bold toppings.

Service at Hartford Steak Co. Tavern complements the food well. Reviews highlight attentive, friendly staff, with Chloe being an example of excellent hospitality—introducing herself and ensuring a smooth dining experience. The tavern’s cozy scale can mean lines during peak hours, especially on Friday and Saturday prime rib nights, but the wait tends to be brief and well worth it.

To conclude the meal, the tavern’s dessert offerings, including a rich Cheesecake and the indulgent Turtle Brownie, provide a sweet finishing touch that sustains the homey, satisfying theme of the meal. The Key Lime Pie is another refreshing choice, balancing sweetness with acidity.

Overall, Hartford Steak Co. Tavern doesn’t chase flash; it delivers on hearty, expertly prepared steaks that rival many steakhouses of the region. Its focus on prime cuts, classic sides, and warm hospitality makes it a highly recommended stop for anyone seeking a dependable steakhouse experience in Vermillion.